You are not currently logged in.
Thursday, May 24 2012

Eye-gouging incident in Maidstone sparks rugby fans' outrage

 

An alleged rugby eye-gouging incident in Maidstone has triggered an internet debate on the state of the sport.

Clarence Harding, 26, was blinded in one eye after being injured while playing for Gravesend against Maidstone on Sunday, January 17.

Police are now investigating the circumstances of the injury.

Reports of the incidents have been posted to rugby websites and the forums of rugby teams across the country since the weekend.

At rugbynetwork.net a fan identified as "Samquin" wrote: "I worry that some idiots think this is part of the game. The RFU needs to be firm. Any club with a continuing poor record of this type of behaviour may need to be penalised to ensure they root out the perpetrators.

"Lifetime bans from playing are necessary."

On the same forum another fan, "Twickenham Yeti" added that the offender, if found guilty, should "serve a substantial sentence of imprisonment to ensure that the game we know and love does not become more discredited."

At therugbyforum.com a player identified only as "Fa'atau82" wrote: "This is actually my local club. I have been gouged before quite seriously and it's affected my vision, so i feel for Clarence. I just hope they get the scum who did this, ban him for life, and for Clarence to get something out of this. It's appaling at any level, but when absolutely nothing is at stake, for me.. it makes it that much more sinister than just trying to get an edge over an opponent."

Let us know your thoughts below.

Gravesend Rugby Club released a statement about the incident at the weekend.

In it Mr Harding, who plays at number eight, described how he felt a finger in his eye while he was on the floor handing the ball back to his teammates.

He added: "It was over in an instant but it dawned on me very quickly that something pretty serious had happened. The ball was nowhere near my head at the time."

Gravesend club chairman Graham Haggar said photographs taken at the time were currently being studied.

The club, currently top of London One South division, has written to Maidstone Rugby Club to demand an investigation.

Mr Haggar said he was "deeply concerned about the horrendous injury" and that no Gravesend player had ever suffered an injury of this kind in the club’s 100 year history.

He added: "We are anxious to cooperate with any investigation to establish exactly what happened in the match and we will support our player and his family in any way we can.

"Without wanting to prejudge an investigation we regard eye-gouging as sly, cowardly and vicious, as does the rest of the rugby fraternity. It has no place in our sport or in any other activity.

"Any player found to have committed such an act should be banned from rugby for life and should face the full weight of the criminal law."

Police say they are investigating an allegation of grievous bodily harm in which a 26-year-old man sustained a "serious injury to his eye" during a rugby match at the sports field at Mote Park, at about 2.20pm on Sunday January 17.

Saturday, January 30 2010

The KM Group does not moderate comments.
Please click here for our house rules.

Comments (6)

Comments closed

  • G. Smith wrote:

    Bias -- Is that the Maidstone RFC resonse?

    I can geuss who posted this. I am sorry to tell you the rest of rugby fraternity see it as it is, a cowardly act by a thug. The victim as you put it was not unlucky as you say, he was violently gouged in his eye socket and blinded for life.
    Hold your head in shame.

    07 Feb 2010 10:50 PM

    Report Abuse

  • G. Smith wrote:

    Cowardly oaf

    I was there at the match, watching my son playing for Gravesend. I did not see how it happened. Whatever happens from now, it is in the interest of rugby union and both clubs and of course Clarence and his family that the cowardly oaf who did this is exposed and dealt with by the law and the RFU.
    Clarence is a nice bloke, his future life is blighted by this, I am in awe of him because of his positive attitude about his future.
    My own personal thoughts about how to deal with the culprit are unprintable.

    07 Feb 2010 9:30 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Matt J wrote:

    Really?

    there is no real way an eye can be harmed that way, that seriously without some intent. there is no sense of bias here, and no one person has been alleged in this article....it is a disgusting outrage and i play for a club local to both of these and hope that this one incident doesn't deter young people from the best sport in the world

    07 Feb 2010 9:30 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Georgie wrote:

    Bias

    I find it very interesting that the only comments you bother to display are those that are biased towards the unlucky victim. There is no sense of fairness or doubt being cast over the allegations or cause of this terrible injury. Please even in this era of blame culture innocent until proven otherwise must prevail.

    02 Feb 2010 10:41 AM

    Report Abuse

  • Cheesy wrote:

    Shocking

    Agree Scoots. I hope whoever did this is found and dealt with appropriately. Poor Lance may now have the rest of his life with only one eye and that is just outrageous. best wishes Lance.

    01 Feb 2010 9:46 AM

    Report Abuse

  • Scooter wrote:

    Unbelievable.

    Absolutely disgusting.
    The cowardly hooligan who committed the horrendous act, must get a life ban from the game AND a lengthy custodial sentance.
    Shameful. Very shameful.

    30 Jan 2010 6:30 PM

    Report Abuse

Terms of Comments
We do not actively moderate, monitor or edit contributions to the reader comments but we may intervene and take such action as we think necessary, please click here for our house rules.. If you have any concerns over the contents on our site, please either register those concerns using the report abuse button, contact us here, email multimediadesk@thekmgroup.co.uk or call 01634 227834.

Advertisement

Copyright: You may not copy, reproduce, republish, download, post, broadcast, transmit or otherwise use content on this site in any way except for your own personal, non-commercial use. You also agree not to adapt, alter or create a derivative work from any content on this site except for your own personal, non-commercial use. Any other use of content requires the prior written permission of the KM GROUP. Read full terms and conditions.