You are not currently logged in.
Thursday, February 09 2012

Judge Nash hits out at 'endemic behaviour' of drunk women

A judge known for his sharp tongue and withering comments has hit out at women who end up "completely plastered, utterly objectionable and violent" after evenings out with friends.

Judge Timothy Nash's remarks were directed at 22-year-old Susan Bruce who was at Canterbury Crown Court to be sentenced for being drunk and disorderly in April and breaching a suspended sentence.

He said the behaviour was "endemic" and diverted police officers who could be better occupied.

It is the same judge who last year told three women he was jailing they had behaved like a "bunch of over-the-hill slappers" in robbing a homeless alcoholic in Canterbury city centre.

On that occasion he was on the receiving end of a public rap by his own peers as a judge at the Court of Appeal took exception and warned him about his use of language.

Bruce had been out on a hen night in Rochester but had been thrown out of a club. Police found her on the floor in a doorway. She had no money and no way of getting home so officers left her in a bus shelter with advice to wait for a limousine due to pick up the hen party.

But police were called back because Bruce was causing trouble for club door staff as she tried to get in to find her friends. She was arrested when she became aggressive, shouting at police officers.

Judge Nash described her as a very stupid girl, adding: "This sort of behaviour is endemic. These girls go out with the best of intentions and end up completely plastered and are utterly objectionable and violent in public places because alcohol is freely available 24 hours a day."

Bruce, of Ulcombe Gardens, Canterbury has a string of convictions going back 2001 for drink-related offences, including assault on police and affray and appeared at the same court in October last year for wounding when she was given 12 months, suspended for two years with a condition she underwent alcohol treatment.

Judge Nash ordered the suspended sentence should continue until it expires in 2010 and ordered a 56-day curfew when Bruce remains indoors between 8pm and 8am and is electronically tagged.

Tuesday, June 30 2009

The KM Group does not moderate comments.
Please click here for our house rules.

Comments (10)

Comments closed

  • terv wrote:

    susan bruce

    clearly there is a problem with this girl instead of hounding her down and forcing her back to drink to block the pain these so called social serveces have not found the route of the problem it is far easier to pass the buck to cover there own back as this is not an isolated case do we need to clean our own house out before takaling the rest of the world

    02 Aug 2009 1:26 AM

    Report Abuse

  • melissa wrote:

    melissa

    dats my cuzen use r talkin about u beta stop aswel cuz u dont even no her u dives ohhh judge dis n judge dat lol

    12 Jul 2009 2:08 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Dave wrote:

    Judge Nash

    Martin P - we don't need straight talking from judges - we need ACTION.
    Why was this woman's suspended jail term from October not enforced. What is the point in passing a sentence on someone and telling them that if they re-offend they'll go to prison, and when they breach those conditions, you pass a spineless sentence effectively letting them off.
    That's really going to help society, isn't it ?

    01 Jul 2009 1:04 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Mike K wrote:

    Judge Nash

    Whatever the judge says and whatever the sentence, does anybody really think that it's going to change a 22 year old with a history of 8 years of alcohol abuse? She started at 14! Her problems are not going to be solved by this. Sooner or later she'll be back ...

    01 Jul 2009 8:55 AM

    Report Abuse

  • Steve wrote:

    Yes, but....

    The availability of alcohol is nothing to do with it. If people had more restraint and self-respect, they wouldn't get into this kind of trouble. She was lucky she wasn't raped or kidnapped, and there would have only be been one person at fault.

    01 Jul 2009 7:51 AM

    Report Abuse

  • Ian Bentley wrote:

    Judge Nash

    No sadder sight than a plastered bird. Somebody should tell 'em.

    01 Jul 2009 12:11 AM

    Report Abuse

  • Robster wrote:

    Judge Nash

    Drink and Drugs are the ruination of society, respect, and obedience.
    This Judge should be made Lord Chief of Justice and write a new rule book especially for the lout's that decent British people live in fear of, so that all his cohort's can treat them the same.

    30 Jun 2009 9:27 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Mr. B wrote:

    Judge Nash

    Violent, drunken people of ANY gender are a drain on Health and Police resources. If you can't behave like a adult and face the consequences of your actions, tough. Why should the rest of us have to put up with you? Judge Nash should be allowed to pass comment, in this case I would say he's entirely justified.

    30 Jun 2009 5:33 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Amanda wrote:

    Judge Nash

    The judge's comment reflects the thinking of most sane people. Its straight forward and honest. How would his critics suggest he describe this woman who has done nothing but waste public resources and money?

    30 Jun 2009 3:21 PM

    Report Abuse

  • Martin P wrote:

    Judge Nash

    Judge Nash should be commended for his statement,there should be more straight talking from Judges regarding the decay in our society.



















    30 Jun 2009 2:11 PM

    Report Abuse

Terms of Comments
We do not actively moderate, monitor or edit contributions to the reader comments but we may intervene and take such action as we think necessary, please click here for our house rules.. If you have any concerns over the contents on our site, please either register those concerns using the report abuse button, contact us here, email multimediadesk@thekmgroup.co.uk or call 01634 227834.

Advertisement

Copyright: You may not copy, reproduce, republish, download, post, broadcast, transmit or otherwise use content on this site in any way except for your own personal, non-commercial use. You also agree not to adapt, alter or create a derivative work from any content on this site except for your own personal, non-commercial use. Any other use of content requires the prior written permission of the KM GROUP. Read full terms and conditions.