You are not currently logged in.
Thursday, June 20 2013

Survivors ask why me?

Herald of Free Enterprise header

Herald of Free Enterprise, March 1987

Why?

That was a question which many people asked after the tragedy. Not only why did it happen, but why did certain people die and others survive?

In some cases, crew members had changed shifts. Those who had taken a day off and were replaced by others were left with huge feelings of guilt.

A Dover lorry driver was asked to go on a sudden trip to Belgium by his employer.

"Why him or her, and not me?"

Others were perplexed as to why people who were known to be strong swimmers had drowned, and others who could not swim had survived.

Wing Commander Ian Hill - one of the world's leading experts in major crash investigations - said his advice to anyone who might find themselves in cold water was: "Float, don't swim.

"Someone who is thin has a very real problem. It is the thickness of fat that acts as insulation.

"The natural reaction is to swim, but you are more likely to survive if you just try to float. The water takes away the heat from your skin.

"If you exercise, you increase the heat in your muscles and you will lose more heat."

Hypothermia, he said, caused pain and discomfort worse than cramp, a tingling and numbness in the fingers and a loss of co-ordination, leading to mistakes being made.

"People are unable to get themselves out of a predicament because they do the wrong things. It is not uncommon for them to take their clothes off. The ability to think is impaired."

Experiments in a swimming pool with the water at four degrees centigrade -the temperature of the sea water that night - had resulted in some proficient swimmers getting into difficulties and sinking within one or two minutes.

A man told how his wife and daughter were washed away in the water, but came up again together and clung to some furniture. He heard his wife say: "I don't think I can hold on much longer." 

He made his way towards them and forced his body up through the tables and chairs to reach her. But he fell unconscious. He survived and woke up in hospital to be told his wife had died.

Coroner Richard Sturt said it was a Herculean task to hold on to someone when you were drowning.

"You made heroic efforts to save her," he said.

"I failed," sobbed the man.

Copyright: You may not copy, reproduce, republish, download, post, broadcast, transmit or otherwise use content on this site in any way except for your own personal, non-commercial use. You also agree not to adapt, alter or create a derivative work from any content on this site except for your own personal, non-commercial use. Any other use of content requires the prior written permission of the KM GROUP. Read full terms and conditions.