Share

Broken cloud

Tue

21°C | 12°C

Clear spells

Wed

23°C | 12°C

Mostly clear

Thu

23°C | 13°C

Home   Thanet   News   Article

Vile Margate pervert Alfred Hynds, 88, 'will die in prison' after catalogue of child rapes and indecent assaults

03 April 2014
by Paul Hooper

A vile elderly sex pervert who attacked two children has been given a sentence that will mean he is expected to die in prison.

Doctors have said 88-year-old Alfred Hynds, from Margate, has only months to live because of lung cancer.

A judge said the Second World War veteran's rapes and indecent assaults on the girls merited 18 years behind bars.

War veteran Alfred Hynds abused two girls. Picture Mike Gunnill

War veteran Alfred Hynds abused two girls. Picture: Mike Gunnill

But because of his age and medical problems, she told Hynds - who walks with a frame - she would cut that sentence to 14 years.

Judge Heather Norton said Hynds had tried to claim he had been the victim, accusing one of the schoolgirls as being "provocative and suggestive" and claiming the second had lied.

But a jury at Canterbury Crown Court rejected his claims and convicted him on all 14 charges of rape and indecent assault.

The judge then ordered the courtroom to be cleared "so he could be taken away by prison staff with dignity".

Hynds, of Cobbs Place, was found guilty after a prolonged trial that began on March 10 and in which the jury had to hear evidence for just two hours a day.

He should have gone on trial in August and then again in January, but on each occasion he claimed he could not face trial because of his medical condition.

His lawyers then appealed to the Attorney General to issue a nolle prosequi, which would have ended the prosecution. It was rejected.

And after studying his medical records and hearing evidence from a hospital consultant via a TV link, the judge ruled that despite his claims, Hynds was fit to stand trial.

Judge Heather Norton passed sentence

Judge Heather Norton passed sentence



The jury then heard of his sex attacks on the girls going back more than 10 years - which included the twisted pervert making and using a model penis.

But prosecutor Janine Sheff told how one of his victims was so traumatised by the paedophile attacks she became an alcoholic and could only have sex with men now when she was drunk.

In a victim impact statement read to the judge, the woman - who is now in her 20s -described the attacks as "emotional torture", adding the "worst aspect was not (initially) being believed".

She said: "I now feel ecstatic that I have been believed."

"He had been sent home to die. He will spend the rest of his life in prison and will die in prison. It is the equivalent to a whole life sentence..." - barrister Paul Hogben

A second victim thanked the jury "for believing me and for changing my life".

Hynds' barrister Paul Hogben turned to Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice to plea for a sentence that would mean he would not have to die in custody.

Quoting from the character Portia's "quality of mercy" speech, Mr Hogben said justice should be seasoned with mercy, adding: "Without mercy, there is no justice."

The barrister said: "I could see at an early stage that there was a compelling and overwhelming case again Mr Hynds.

"And I could see that at the end of the trial process would result in the court deciding whether to imprison a man for the remainder of his life."

He then quoted from Banks, the judges' "Bible", saying that "it must always be remembered that sentencing is an art rather than a science... that leniency is not in itself a vice and that mercy should season justice is as soundly based in law as it is in literature".

Mr Hogben said Hynds had been told in January he had less than a year to live, he has a pacemaker, his heart is working at 35% and his breathing at 65%.

"He had been sent home to die, he said. "He will spend the rest of his life in prison and will die in prison. It is the equivalent to a whole life sentence."

The case was heard at Canterbury Crown Court

The case was heard at Canterbury Crown Court



But the judge told Hynds she could not take "a wholly exceptional" course after hearing that the prison authorities said his medical condition could be managed inside jail.

She added: "There is no authority of which I am aware which states that it is be wrong in principle to pass such a sentence and it is not for me to try to predict when the end of your life will be."


 Stories you might have missed

Hoax text claims boy fights for life in crash

X Factor winner announces Kent concert

Teen recovers after storm drain ordeal

The wrong kind of pheasant? 


 

Click here for more news from Thanet.

Click here for more news from around the county.

Comments 

Forgotten Password?

Forgotten Username?

Don't have an account? Please Register first!

The KM Group does not moderate comments.
Please click here for our house rules.

Thank you. Your comment has been received and will appear on the site shortly.

 

Terms of Comments
We do not actively moderate, monitor or edit contributions to the reader comments but we may intervene and take such action as we think necessary, please click here for our house rules.. If you have any concerns over the contents on our site, please either register those concerns using the report abuse button, contact us here, email multimediadesk@thekmgroup.co.uk or call 01634 227989.