Home   Canterbury   News   Article

East Kent hospital changes to be decided by doctors, not the public, MP Damian Green told

By Joe Wright

Leading doctors say radical changes to healthcare in east Kent will not be decided by a referendum like Brexit.

The divisive plans for a shake-up of services at the Kent & Canterbury, William Harvey and QEQM hospitals are in the process of being discussed by residents and patients at a series of consultation events.

The NHS is exploring two options for reconfiguring the three main east Kent hospitals.

Kent and Canterbury Hospital
Kent and Canterbury Hospital

The first would see all specialist services move to the William Harvey, with the K&C heavily downgraded, while the second option offers a ‘super hospital’ in Canterbury where there would be a sole A&E department for hundreds of thousands of patients.

But, instead of being decided upon by the public, the final outcome will fall on the heavy shoulders of the chairmen at east Kent’s four clinical commissioning groups, known as CCGs.

In an email to Ashford MP Damian Green, the medical professionals shut down the belief that the most popular of the two options on the table will be chosen, and branded the hopes for a public vote as “misleading and wrong”.

They said: “To suggest that the process is similar to political democratic processes like elections or referendums is a fundamental misunderstanding of public consultation on plans to change NHS services.

“Consultation influences the final proposals, but it does not decide the outcome.

“The four clinical commissioning groups in east Kent are the statutory NHS organisations responsible for making a final decision.

"While some people may disagree with this, they are wrong to suggest that we are not following the correct process.”

Since the full details were revealed in October, a series of public meetings have been held, allowing residents to voice their thoughts on the proposals.

“To suggest that the process is similar to political democratic processes like elections or referendums is a fundamental misunderstanding of public consultation on plans to change NHS services..." - Clinical commissioning group chairmen

Hundreds of people have attended the events, with ambulance travel times, recruitment challenges and the availability of hospital services being the main issues raised.

The key decision-makers continued: “Their [residents’] views will be used to shape the proposals and where they highlight concerns will allow us to consider what can be done to remove or minimise those concerns. But consultation is not a vote.

“We absolutely want to hear people’s views.”

The leading medical professionals - Dr Jihad Malasi, Dr Navin Kumta, Dr Simon Dunn, Dr Jonathan Bryant and hospital trust director Dr Paul Stevens - have also put to bed hopes for a third option.

Dr Simon Dunn of Canterbury and Coastal CCG
Dr Simon Dunn of Canterbury and Coastal CCG
Dr Jonathan Bryant of South Kent Coast CCG
Dr Jonathan Bryant of South Kent Coast CCG
Dr Jihad Malasi from Thanet CCG
Dr Jihad Malasi from Thanet CCG
Dr Navin Kumta from Ashford CCG
Dr Navin Kumta from Ashford CCG
East Kent Hospital Trust medical trust Dr Paul Stevens
East Kent Hospital Trust medical trust Dr Paul Stevens

The Save our NHS in Kent (SONiK) group, which has gained more than 3,400 signatures, has been calling on health chiefs to consider offering A&E services at all three hospitals.

But in their letter to Mr Green MP, the leading doctors said “we cannot put such an option into a public consultation... it has already been considered and ruled out”.

“Doing nothing is not an option, nor is proposing unrealistic options that would not be in the best interests of the residents of east Kent. With complex specialist services it is not possible to have everything at every hospital.”

Statistics used by SONiK claim “mortality could rise by 2.3%” as a result of closing and restructuring emergency departments.

The claim, however, has been debunked by the CCG chairmen, who cite there is no relevant evidence from the 2009-2011 report.

A final decision is expected on the proposals following a last round of public consultation early next year.

Join the debate...
Comments |

Don't have an account? Please Register first!

The KM Group does not moderate comments. Please click here for our house rules.

People who post abusive comments about other users or those featured in articles will be banned.

Thank you. Your comment has been received and will appear on the site shortly.

 

Terms of Comments
We do not actively moderate, monitor or edit contributions to the reader comments but we may intervene and take such action as we think necessary, please click here for our house rules. If you have any concerns over the contents on our site, please either register those concerns using the report abuse button, contact us here, email multimediadesk@thekmgroup.co.uk or call 01634 227989.

Follow us

Like Us on Facebook

Most popular

Kent Travel News

Close This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.Learn More