Home   Dartford   News   Article

Dartford resident Jorge Garay denies murdering partner during Peru holiday

A mother was strangled by her "bullying and jealous" partner who used a cord wrapped twice around her neck, a murder jury was told today.

Jorge Garay is alleged to have carried out the attack while he and Karla Godoy were on holiday in Peru last September.

Jorge Garay is on trial accused of killing his lover Karla Zelaya Godoy while in Peru. Picture: Jam Press
Jorge Garay is on trial accused of killing his lover Karla Zelaya Godoy while in Peru. Picture: Jam Press

The 46-year-old Dartford resident has denied murder but admits he caused her death during a furious row and then buried in a makeshift grave.

The trial is believed to be the first brought under a 2021 Act which allows a defendant to be tried in the UK, even though the killing happened 6,000 miles away.

Prosecutor Philip Bennetts told Maidstone Crown Court: "The cause of death was mechanical asphyxia.

"The position of the chord suggests he applied force to Karla's body from behind. A chord had been wrapped twice around her neck."

A British pathologist later told police: "It is generally accepted that continuous pressure around the neck for between 15 to 30 seconds is required before a person will lose consciousness.

“This pressure then has to be continued for at least a minute to cause death."

Jorge Garay is on trial accused of killing his lover Karla Zelaya Godoy while in Peru. Picture: Jam Press
Jorge Garay is on trial accused of killing his lover Karla Zelaya Godoy while in Peru. Picture: Jam Press

Mr Bennetts told the jury: "The evidence suggests Garay was a bullying, controlling and jealous man and one of the factors that made him jealous was when Karla was going to see her daughter from a previous relationship."

The couple had been holidaying in the South American country when she went missing.

Honduras-born Karla, 37, was due to fly to Spain but failed to make her flight and was reported missing by her family.

Garay, of Hythe Street, Dartford, later called a Peruvian policeman telling him he had hit his partner, it was claimed.

"He said he had buried her body in Carabayllo [near the capial city Lima], telling the officer: "We had an argument. She wanted to attack me with a knife. I defended myself. I punched her. One punch. I buried her," said Mr Bennetts.

In a prepared statement, Garay claimed he and Karla had spent a week in Lima, adding: "We had recently been arguing about her ex-partner and their 10 year old daughter. The ex-partner had custody of Karla's daughter.

Maidstone Crown Court
Maidstone Crown Court

"This was causing her a lot of stress. She was suffering mentally because of this. I think she was depressed."

On the evening of her death, the accused claimed Karla had been "mad and angry". Garay, who worked with his partner at a Dartford-based cleaning company, told how they had visited the UNESCO World Heritage Site Machu Piccu and had been photographed together.

Days later they were sat in a kitchen when Karla said she had received messages from her former partner.

He said: "I told her to ignore the messages and calls [that he] had made to her. I told her to ignore him. Not to let him spoil our holiday.

"I told her that she was sh*t and at that point she slapped me hard in the face and was calling me the most hurtful names...that I was a sh*t and that I had no right telling her what to do...that I am no-one. I slapped her back."

He then claimed his girlfriend grabbed a wooden knife and lashed out at him. Karla's body was later found by police in a shallow grave a few miles away. The trial continues.

Close This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.Learn More